Handheld Scanners

Technology overview:

Handheld 3D scanners used in 3D photography typically rely on structured light to calculate the geometry of the subject being 3D scanned. They were designed for and have numerous applications in engineering.

Average Cost:

$400 to $30,000

How it works:

3D scanning someone with a handheld 3D scanner works by having the person stand still as you slowly move the 3D scanner around them to capture the different parts of their body. The process normally takes 2-3 minutes. Once the data has been captured, some manual intervention is necessary to match resulting point clouds, then it takes another 2-3 minutes to generate a full 3D model.

Limitations:

The biggest limitation for handheld 3D scanners is the need for people to stand still throughout the scanning process. Even small amounts of movement can destroy the data and require the entire scan be restarted. Structured light handheld 3D scanners, also struggle with scanning transparent materials (ex: lenses on glasses) or reflective surfaces (ex: shiny car parts).

Post production:

A scan of a single person is usually comprised of many smaller scans which first need to be matched either programmatically or by hand or by a combination of both depending on the quality of the data and the sophistication of the software. Once the points clouds have been matched and meshed into a 3D model, the amount of geometry retouching is minimal if the subject stayed perfectly still.

If the person moves then fixing the geometry can take significantly longer to the point where it may make sense to just scan the person again. Depending on the lighting conditions and how much the subject moves while scanning, the amount of time to touch-up texture problems can vary significantly and become quite dramatic. Since handheld scanners are by definition handheld, they do not have lighting setups to cast consistent 360 degree lighting, which usually results in uneven lighting and shadows which need to be fixed in post processing. Professional 3D artist are more than capable of performing the post-production touch-ups. You should expect to pay $15-$25 per 3D scan to prepare it for 3D printing.

Pros:

• Portability – a handheld 3D scanner can be put in a small briefcase and transported very easily. Setup time is usually less than 5 minutes.
• Scan processing time – since a handheld 3D scanner uses structured light to calculate depth, the required computation is much less than a DSLR photogrammetry systems. The time to a full 3D model is 2-3 minutes.
• Fine geometry detail – structured light handheld scanners were designed to scan very small parts with intricate detail so they do an excellent job of capturing geometry detail.

Cons:

• Subjects need to be still for 2-3 minutes – In order for handheld 3D scanners to work well, you need people to be as still as possible or risk either ruining the scan or creating serious headaches in post-production. Some handheld scanner users even suggest holding your breath during the scanning process. Most kids/pets (and even many adults) are unsuited for being scanned with a handheld scanner.
• No controlled lighting –Just like in regular photography, lighting makes all the difference in creating high quality 3D scans. Since handheld scanners do not control for lighting, the resulting scan will have all the lighting inconsistencies present in the environment. This can result in an excessive amount of time needed to fix the colors on the 3D scan in the post production process.
• Lower quality texture – In order to capture color detail, handheld 3D scanners take pictures at regular intervals during the scanning process then blend all of those photos into a single texture. Many of the cameras built into handheld scanners are not of great quality so the resulting photographs are of poorer quality. In addition, because the pictures are blended together, any movement by the subject causes blurring in the resulting texture.

Conclusion:

Handheld scanners are great for scanning stationary objects with fine details, but struggle when used for 3D scanning people or pets. Handheld scanners were a great option in the past due to their portability and low cost, however, there are now specialized full-body scanners that excel at scanning people and pets at a similar price point that can also be carried around, albeit not nearly as easily.